P U N D I T  R U M B L E The Tape Debates Scores This week Insights
← All topics

The U.S. Economy

75 bullish · 64 bearish · 1 hold · 52 neutral · exact words, dated and sourced
Tom LeeJason CalacanisDavid SacksEd YardeniCathie WoodChamath+95

Recession, resilience, or ho-hum: reads on the consumer, jobs, and growth.

The count, last 30 days: 24 bullish, 40 bearish. The tape leans bearish. A count, not a verdict.

The tape

Aug 03
Aug 10
Aug 17
Aug 24
Aug 31
Sep 07
bullishbearishclaims filed per week

What the people who move markets are saying about this, in their own words. These are views on the record, not scored bets: when a call here grows a number and a deadline, it moves to the scoreboard. Newest first.

Bearish 2026-09-10
Deepak Mehra says the US economy is weaker than it looks: growth has slowed to 1.5% and even that is mostly AI infrastructure spending.
even if you look at the GDP growth we were running at two point one percent last year and now at one point five percent which is also predominantly due to huge AI infrastructure spend
Deepak Mehra · Commercial Bank of Dubai (chief economist) · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a0c88npBIck @16:44 ↗
Neutral hedged · 2026-09-10
Jack Caffrey tells the anchor the US consumer only gets into much better shape once energy prices normalise, which acts like a weekly tax cut at the pump.
I realistically think the consumer will be in much better shape when we see greater normalization in energy prices.
Bearish leaning · 2026-09-10
Ed Dufner tells the anchor Trump's $5,000 'Trump dividend' is unlikely to come to pass: no funding source, no legislative framework and Republican pushback in Congress.
It's a pretty remarkable suggestion, Bonnie, and I think you actually hit on the idea that it's difficult to come to pass.
Neutral hedged · 2026-09-10
Donald Trump pledges a $5,000 'Trump dividend' to every adult US citizen if Republicans keep both the House and Senate in November 2026.
If the Republicans win the House of Representatives and the United States Senate, both of them, I will issue a dividend to every adult citizen in the United States of America for $5,000.
Bearish leaning · 2026-09-10
Michael Reid tells the anchor inflation-indexed entitlement spending adds to the deficit and that realisation is what pressures the long end of the Treasury curve.
That is adding to the deficit. And so when you're thinking about the long end of the curve, that's where a lot of this pressure is coming from the realization that this is not a problem, that is easily solved.
Neutral leaning · 2026-09-10
Charlie Scharf says consumer credit is very healthy with delinquencies improving, though that will not continue forever.
The delinquencies are actually improving from very very healthy levels already. We don't expect that to continue. It's not going to go on forever but the health of the consumer from a credit perspective is really strong.
Neutral 2026-09-10
Brian Moynihan says consumers are borrowing and credit quality is good.
They're borrowing. They're using the lines. The credit quality is good.
Bullish 2026-09-10
McGlone tells Lin he is very worried about touching the stock market and that 5% Treasuries are the place to be.
I would say very worried about touching the stock market. I just look at that 5% bond treasuries is the place to be.
Mike McGlone · Bloomberg Intelligence senior commodity strategist · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0z4b9oYw3Y @27:27 ↗
Bullish 2026-09-10
McGlone tells Lin long bonds (TLT) are essentially a positive-carry put on the S&P 500 waiting for a stock-market trigger.
If you look at TLT or bonds is basically, it's essentially a put on the S&P 500 with positive carry, no time decay, and it's just waiting around for a trigger.
Mike McGlone · Bloomberg Intelligence senior commodity strategist · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0z4b9oYw3Y @29:36 ↗
Bullish 2026-09-10
Tom Lee says the US economy looks really good, citing well-behaved high-yield spreads over the yield curve as a recession signal.
I think it looks really good. Now I'm going to point to something that has been a really good predictor of recessions
Neutral hedged · 2026-09-09
Sunny Bangia (Bloomberg equity strategist) sizes Bessent's Treasury buyback room at just under $400B (TGA ~$900B drawn to $500B), i.e. a $10-15B program that can move yields short term but not fix why they rise
So, the Treasury general account has built up to about 900 billion, just under $900 billion. If he looks to bring that down to 500 billion, so he's got room with about just shy of $400 billion worth of buying that he can do.
Bearish 2026-09-09
Lee says Treasury buybacks may squeeze shorts short term but will not lastingly lower yields because deficits, not mechanics, set the long end
But these plans, in our view, are not going to change the fundamental situation, which is the US government still continues to run significant amount of deficit despite the fact that you have positive growth.
US 10-yr yield since this was said: 4.84% → 4.94% (+11 bp) · as of 2026-09-10
Neutral 2026-09-09
Louis-Vincent Gave (Gavekal) says the US budget deficit will be 7% of GDP this year at full employment, with France near 6%
US budget deficit this year is going to be 7% of GDP. Six years into an economic recovery with full employment. France is probably going to be at six.
Bearish 2026-09-09
Gave says easy fiscal, easy money, protectionism and wars are each bearish bonds, so it is hard to get excited about bonds until one changes
So any one of these factors would be bearish bonds. You put them all forth together and you have what we have. Bond yields rising every day. And I think until one of these things changes, it's pretty hard to get that fired up about bonds.
Bearish hedged · 2026-09-09
Cranfield would not be surprised if US Treasury yields are a bit higher within a week given deficits, auctions and buyback-disappointment risk
And it wouldn't be too surprising if by a week's time yields are a bit higher in the United States.
Bearish leaning · 2026-09-09
Rhee says fiscal expansion plus leveraged AI investment drives rising yields and higher bond yields will persist unless governments rein in spending
unless the government, the advanced economics government, government shows that they can rule these fiscal expenditures, I think this higher bond yield will come.
Neutral hedged · 2026-09-09
John Burn-Murdoch (FT) offers the hedged view that falling education scores may matter less for GDP than feared because top performers drive the economy
A more perhaps controversial take, as it were, that I could give to this is that I think some of this stuff actually may matter less than we think for the economy.
Bearish 2026-09-09
Ed Elson (Prof G Markets host, own monologue) says long-term Treasury yields are high because investors do not believe the US takes fiscal responsibility seriously
That is why long-term treasury yields are so high right now. Investors simply don't believe that fiscal responsibility is something we take seriously at all.
Bearish 2026-09-09
Elson says America's debt problem ($40T debt, $1.25T interest) is at a tipping point and will probably never be taken seriously
America's debt problem is reaching a tipping point. It is worse than ever before. And if we continue to not take it seriously today, then I think the conclusion is quite obvious. We probably never will.
Bearish 2026-09-09
Heath expects US long-end yields to keep rising because leveraged hedge funds have replaced central banks as the marginal Treasury buyer
And it looks with hedge funds being kind of the marginal material buyer, those rates are gonna go up at the long end.
Bearish hedged · 2026-09-09
Heath senses the world is moving into a contraction-type environment, while distrusting official statistics
But it does feel that generally like the world's kind of moving into more of a contraction type environment.
Neutral 2026-09-09
David McIntosh tells Fox Business that Republicans will win the November 2026 midterms and keep the House, rejecting forecasts that they lose it.
I disagree. I think Republicans are going to win this very competitive midterm race, and here in Dallas you can feel it already.
Neutral 2026-09-08
Eisenschmidt says an ECB hike to 2.50% at next week's meeting is out of question and fully priced.
So the ECB is clearly set to go to 250 to hike. That I think is out of question.
Hold hedged · 2026-09-08
Eisenschmidt says Morgan Stanley thinks the September ECB hike is the last (market prices two more), predicated on growth softening and energy prices stopping their rise.
The market currently is pricing two more hikes. We think this is it. But of course, this is predicated on that the business cycle at some point starts to show weakness and that energy prices stop rising further.
Bearish 2026-09-08
Hambro says yields are rising because investors demand a higher return for lending to over-indebted, inefficient governments, with implications across assets.
the real reason I think the yields are going up is people are saying well if I want to lend money to a government that is spending that money badly and inefficiently I need a higher return for that.
Bullish hedged · 2026-09-08
Ven Ram expects the UK's record-cost gilt sale to be well digested given only a mild concession.
to the extent that the concession is is nominal and mild I think it's a it's going to be well digested by the markets.
Neutral leaning · 2026-09-08
Ven Ram says the gilt selloff is part of a global rise in long-end yields because the equilibrium rate has risen with heavy debt supply, not a UK-specific aversion.
there is nothing to suggest that you know there is an aversion to guilt as per say what we are seeing is a global increase in yields particularly at the long end
Bearish hedged · 2026-09-08
Peter Schiff suggests the August jobs beat reported on Friday may be revised down to a miss by December, undercutting the case for hikes.
we may find out that the jobs numbers that were reported as a beat on Friday, they may be revised down to a miss by December.
Bearish 2026-09-08
Peter Schiff says that even with unchanged rates US interest on the national debt will exceed $2 trillion a year by the time Trump leaves office.
by the time Trump leaves office, we'll be spending more than two trillion a year in interest on the national debt.
Bearish 2026-09-08
Peter Schiff says the national debt will go from $40 trillion to $50 trillion much faster than it went from $30 to $40 trillion, pressuring the dollar and lifting gold.
We're going to go from 40 trillion to 50 trillion a lot faster than we went from 30 trillion to 40 trillion.
Bearish 2026-09-08
Peter Schiff tells investors to stay out of cash and out of US bonds because inflation destroys fixed income; own gold, silver and foreign stocks instead.
I've been very clear over the years, stay out of cash, stay out of bonds.
Bullish 2026-09-06
Steve Moore tells Fox Business the August jobs report was a blockbuster with almost nothing bad in it.
It was a blockbuster report, almost nothing bad in this report.
Steve Moore · Committee to Unleash Prosperity / WABC host · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dOB9sCzvaXU @0:38 ↗
Bullish 2026-09-06
Bensignor says the US 10-year yield could go to 5.6% or as high as 10%; he does not expect 10% but calls 5.6% a minimum upside target.
we could easily go to five point six to as much as ten and I don't think we're going there but even five point six would be a minimum upside target here
Bullish 2026-09-06
Bensignor reaffirms his March call that the 10-year will not see 4% again this cycle and rates go higher, with an ultimate target in the 6-7% area.
told clients you will not see four percent again in this cycle rates are going higher and my ultimate target I'm gonna put it here yeah six point oh seven point oh seven
Bullish 2026-09-06
Bullard says 20-30 aggregated labor indicators show the US labor market in equilibrium near the natural rate; a soft payroll print reflects immigration policy, not something breaking.
it will tell you that the labor market is basically in equilibrium. It's very close to the unemployment rates, very close to the natural rate of unemployment. So everything is healthy about the labor market.
Jim Bullard · former president, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDgW9IennTE @10:01 ↗
Bearish leaning · 2026-09-06
Bullard says the long end is pricing a US debt path to 120-150% of GDP and investors are starting to demand a fiscal risk premium (higher long yields).
And the path is to head to 120 percent of debt held by the public or 150 percent of debt held by the public. And the market has to price whether they're going to demand a risk premium for that. I think that they are
Jim Bullard · former president, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDgW9IennTE @11:06 ↗
US 30-yr yield since this was said: 5.24% → 5.28% (+4 bp) · as of 2026-09-09
Neutral 2026-09-06
Bullard says Treasury stepping into the long end is a tactical move that can cause daily fluctuation but will not change the long-run trend, which prices fundamental policy.
But I don't think you disrupt the long run trend by changing tactics.
Jim Bullard · former president, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDgW9IennTE @13:12 ↗
US 30-yr yield since this was said: 5.24% → 5.28% (+4 bp) · as of 2026-09-09
Bearish leaning · 2026-09-04
Wendy Edelberg (Brookings) is puzzled by 71k average payroll growth, seven times last year's pace, with nothing else in the labor market corroborating it.
I am very puzzled actually by the strength in the payroll numbers so at 71,000 on average for the last three months that's like seven times faster than the pace of job growth last year. I see nothing else in the labor market that suggests that kind of pickup and activity.
Neutral 2026-08-28
Paffrath says the 10-year yield is almost back up to 4.7% after Warsh's speech, which is not ideal.
I could see the 10-year is almost back up to 4.7 after this speech.
Neutral 2026-08-26
Rule tells Lin the US government has moved from short-end intervention to intervening in the long end of the Treasury market.
The US government is beginning to do something very different now, which is to intervene in the long-term market.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lYQw_7Myw2g @5:01 ↗
Neutral hedged · 2026-08-26
Rule tells Lin that without intervention, and assuming 8% underlying inflation, a free market would price the 30-year Treasury near 9.5%.
If you assume that the underlying inflation rate is 8%, that would suggest a 30-year treasury rate of 9.5% or 150 basis points over the deterioration of the value of the purchasing power.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lYQw_7Myw2g @11:57 ↗
Bearish 2026-08-26
Rule tells Lin the US economy's low cost of capital rests on artificially low rates and savers subsidizing spenders, which he calls fraud.
Make no mistake, the economy that we enjoy today is based on fraud, based on innovation, based on a whole bunch of things, but importantly, based on fraud.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lYQw_7Myw2g @12:38 ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-26
Rule tells Lin the economy is substantially stronger than he expected despite war, high rates and trade wars, and he cannot see how it is a bad economy that needs lower interest rates.
I'm at a loss to explain the economic strength that we're enjoying, and I'm at a loss to explain how the government can conjure this as a bad economy, one that needs lower interest rates.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lYQw_7Myw2g @34:25 ↗
Bullish hedged · 2026-08-24
Todd Horwitz tells David Lin he would not be surprised to see the 10-year yield above 5% within six weeks because the Treasury buyback intervention will fail.
I would not be surprised within the next six weeks if we hit over 5% in the 10-year notes because of this intervention
Bearish 2026-08-24
Todd Horwitz would sell 10-yr note futures at 109 and 30-yr futures at 110, expecting rates higher and bond prices lower.
In the 10 year notes, they're trading at 108.18 right now. I'd be a seller at 109, okay? And in the 30 years, I'm a seller at 110
Neutral 2026-08-24
Todd Horwitz asserts hidden consumer-credit stress (18% of card holders 90 days past due, 8% auto and 7% mortgage defaults) as the reason the Treasury intervention will fail.
that 18% of the people are 90 days past two on their credit card. 8% are defaulting on their car loan. 7% are defaulting on their mortgages.
Bearish 2026-08-24
Todd Horwitz thinks the US economy is in horrible shape.
not that I think the economy is in horrible shape, which I do
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-24
Todd Horwitz expects food to get more expensive and sees grains as cheap versus production cost with positive momentum building.
I think food's gonna get more expensive, but I think we have finally seen, for our farmers and producers, you finally see a little positive momentum in the grain markets.
Bearish 2026-08-24
Todd Horwitz says cattle, down about 20% from highs, has a lot more downside.
I mean, we've seen cattle has dropped about 20% from its highs, and I think there's still a lot of room to the downside.
Bullish 2026-08-24
Todd Horwitz says interest rates have no chance of falling further unless a financial calamity forces the Fed back into a 2008-style program.
Interest rates are only down a little bit and they're still much higher than they were and they have no chance of coming down further unless there's a financial calamity
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-17
Stephanie Link (Hightower) tells Andrew Ross Sorkin the Atlanta Fed's 5.8% is too high but US growth is accelerating from last quarter on AI capex and a consumer that keeps spending.
I don't think we're growing that fast, Andrew, but I do think we directionally we're accelerating from last quarter.
Neutral 2026-08-17
Stephanie Link (Hightower) tells CNBC ISM services has expanded for 20 straight months, one of several data points showing the economy is healthy.
We have ISM services that are up 20 consecutive months in a row.
Bearish 2026-08-16
Corey Brooks (Chicago pastor, Project H.O.O.D.) predicts New York's government-run grocery stores will fail like Chicago's $13.5m taxpayer-backed plan did.
They always fail and that same thing is going to happen in New York as well.
Bearish 2026-08-16
Jeff Booth (EgoDeath Capital) tells Scott Melker that global debt is mathematically unpayable and the credit-based system will keep degrading and debasing currency.
Global debt can't be repaid. It's impossible. So all of the things from that system get worse and worse and worse.
Bearish hedged · 2026-08-14
Tim Waterer (KCM Trade) reads unchanged 10-year yields despite soft CPI, PPI and jobs as the bond market being more worried about the long-term US economy than the Fed is.
maybe the bond market a little bit more worried about the US economy longer term than what the Fed is, perhaps.
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-14
Steve Liesman tells CNBC viewers not to read much into the July retail sales miss: consumers are coping with high gasoline prices and alternative data showed decent sales.
I would not take a big signal from one number here. Consumers have found a way to find their way through higher gasoline prices.
Bearish hedged · 2026-08-14
Julian Emanuel of Evercore tells Bloomberg his main worry for stocks is the 10-year yield pushing through 4.75% toward 5% as the 30-year makes cycle highs.
So our concern, if there was one in particular, would be if the 10-year yields started nudging through 4 and 3/4 towards 5% as the 30-year yield has made new cycle highs.
Neutral 2026-08-14
Rick Santelli of CNBC reports the August prelim Michigan sentiment headline at 51 versus 55 expected, the weakest since June's 49.5, calling them weak numbers.
51 is the headline number. That's four points lower than the 55 expected. That would be the weakest since we're back under 50 in June when we're at 49 and a half.
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-14
Steve Liesman of CNBC says the July retail sales miss is one number not a signal, since alternative data show consumers coping with higher gasoline prices.
I would not take a big signal from one number here. Consumers have found a way to find their way through higher gasoline prices.
Bullish hedged · 2026-08-14
Steve Liesman (CNBC) says not to read much into the weak July retail sales print; alternative data show consumers finding their way through higher gasoline prices.
I would not take a big signal from one number here. Consumers have found a way to find their way through, higher gasoline prices.
Bearish 2026-08-14
Leon Cooperman tells CNBC he is very negative on the bond market because of the fiscal deficit and bipartisan neglect of the debt.
I'm very negative with the bond market, mainly because of the fiscal deficit and the fact that the Republicans and the Democrats are not paying any attention to the debt build-up of the country.
US 10-yr yield since this was said: 4.70% → 4.94% (+25 bp) · as of 2026-09-10
Neutral 2026-08-14
Eric Rosengren tells Bloomberg that H1 consumption grew only 1.5%, far weaker than investment, so AI/tech capex rather than the consumer is driving the economy.
So if you look at consumption over the first two quarters it only grew at one and a half percent. So that's weaker than the overall economy. It's a lot weaker than what's been happening investment.
Neutral leaning · 2026-08-14
Eric Rosengren tells Bloomberg the economy is growing at roughly the appropriate rate, maybe a little weaker than desired, because the consumer is lethargic.
So I had the economy is growing probably at the appropriate rate overall maybe a little bit weaker than we'd like. And a lot of that is because the consumer has continued to be somewhat lethargic.
Bearish leaning · 2026-08-14
Naveen Jaggi of JLL tells Bloomberg that value retailers like Walmart and Costco are winning while aspirational retailers will feel pain in back-to-school and again in the holidays.
But I think that aspirational retailer they'll be feeling that pain in the back to school shopping. I think they'll get that concern back during the holidays.
Neutral leaning · 2026-08-14
Katherine Black of Kearney tells Bloomberg the weak retail sales print is a cumulative effect not a cliff, with lower-income consumers trading down more sharply than before.
So yeah I don't think it's a huge shock. I don't think we're falling off a cliff or anything. But consumers are still trying to try trading down and we do see lower incomes consumers spending less and trading out of some things that are not discretionary.
Neutral 2026-08-14
Katherine Black of Kearney tells Bloomberg that over 90% of consumers in Kearney's survey say they are changing their shopping behavior.
Consumers are still spending but 90 over 90 percent of consumers tell us that they're changing their behavior.
Neutral 2026-08-14
Katherine Black of Kearney tells Bloomberg value retailers are gaining high-income shoppers, with almost 30% of high-income consumers switching stores.
They're seeing more high income consumers trading into their stores and almost 30 percent of high income consumers say they're changing the store that they're shopping at.
Bearish hedged · 2026-08-14
Katherine Black of Kearney tells Bloomberg that younger consumers propping up spending via buy-now-pay-later could pull back if defaults rise or credit-reporting rules bite.
If we start to see big risk increases big defaults or big shifts in policy now that buy now pay later is reported on credit reports that could really change shopping for that segment.
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-14
Yung-Yu Ma (PNC) tells CNBC he is not concerned about retail sales or the consumer holding the rally back; the real risk to the rally is long-term interest rates rising further.
I don't think consumers are going to be what holds this rally back. I think if anything holds this rally back, it would be if long-term interest rates in particular continue to rise higher from the levels where they are today.
Neutral 2026-08-14
Jason Calacanis predicts to Sacks that New Jersey's AG and NYC Mayor Mamdani will win their lawsuits against Amazon's delivery-subcontractor model.
Landami and New Jersey are going to win these lawsuits. I predict it now.
Neutral leaning · 2026-08-14
David Sacks tells Calacanis forcing Amazon to employ DSP drivers would raise costs about $5.20 per package and $664 per household per year and put ~5,000 jobs at risk.
But I'm not sure it will. What we do know it will do is raise the cost of packages by about $5.20 per package. And it will cost families $664 more per year.
Bullish hedged · 2026-08-13
Siegel tells CNBC AI-driven productivity should pick up in Q3 and Q4 2026 after lagging in H1.
And productivity, which has lagged the first two quarters of this year, but it looks like it might really pick up in this third and fourth quarter.
Bearish leaning · 2026-08-13
Patrick McHenry (Bloomberg politics contributor, ex-House Financial Services chair) says the record 30-year auction yield shows the bond market is again speaking loudly to Washington about overspending, with the Warsh Fed stepping back and letting markets speak.
I think we're getting back to those days where the bond market can speak and speak quite loudly to Washington
Patrick McHenry · Bloomberg politics contributor; former chairman, House Financial Services Committee · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nlw5Z4lnxuk @9:44 ↗
US 30-yr yield since this was said: 5.21% → 5.28% (+7 bp) · as of 2026-09-09
Bearish 2026-08-13
Patrick McHenry says the US is on course for its largest non-wartime structural deficit as a share of GDP and in total, and the bond selloff is a heart-attack-style wake-up call.
This is also comes at a time where the federal government's on course to have the largest structural deficit. It's had outside of wartime as a percentage of the GDP and in total terms.
Patrick McHenry · Bloomberg politics contributor; former chairman, House Financial Services Committee · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nlw5Z4lnxuk @11:28 ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-13
Patrick McHenry thinks capital-gains indexing and a home-sale tax exemption are popular, would be a psychological positive for markets, and could pass relatively easily before the midterms.
No I think it's a popular issue and I think it would be a reassuring push to the market. It would be a psychological improvement rather than a very quick economic improvement.
Patrick McHenry · Bloomberg politics contributor; former chairman, House Financial Services Committee · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nlw5Z4lnxuk @16:52 ↗
Neutral 2026-08-13
Patrick McHenry says the federal government now pays more in interest than on national security, so small tax tweaks are marginal next to overspending.
We're paying now more on interest payments than we are on national security as a federal government.
Patrick McHenry · Bloomberg politics contributor; former chairman, House Financial Services Committee · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nlw5Z4lnxuk @17:49 ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-08-13
Rahm Emanuel tells the All-In hosts that nearly two-thirds, he thinks 63%, of Americans now live paycheck to paycheck because incomes have stagnated.
we have a greater share now of Americans living paycheck to paycheck. That is almost two thirds. I think it's 63% of Americans.
Bearish 2026-08-13
David Friedberg tells Rahm Emanuel the US fiscal position is untenable: $7T spend vs $5T revenue, $40T debt at 5% implying ~$2T a year of interest.
We're 2 trillion short. We've got 40 trillion a debt 30 years at 5%. That's 2 trillion a year in interest expense.
Bearish 2026-08-13
Mark Zandi says falling real disposable income and a near-record-low saving rate cannot be sustained, so US consumer spending will slow.
this can't be sustained for very long and consumer spending will slow.
Neutral 2026-08-13
Mark Zandi, disputing Bessent's claim that the K-shaped economy is over, says the top 20% of earners account for 60% of spending and the K is in full force.
folks in the top 20% of the income distribution account for 60% of the spending.
Bearish 2026-08-13
Mark Zandi says the US job market is struggling: net job growth outside healthcare is zero and falling participation masks weakness.
my sense is the job market's struggling. We're not creating any jobs.
Bearish 2026-08-13
Mark Zandi says that if labor-force participation had not fallen over the past year the unemployment rate would be over 5%.
arithmetic and you assume that the labor force participation rate had not changed from where it was a year ago, the unemployment rate would be over 5%.
Neutral 2026-08-13
Mark Zandi grades the US economy a C minus: 2% growth, not enough to create jobs or make people feel comfortable.
I'd give it a C minus. It's growing. We're getting 2% growth, but it's not enough growth to create any jobs
Neutral 2026-08-13
Mark Zandi says the US is not in and not close to a recession, but the economy is in an uncomfortable, fragile place.
So it's not a recession. I don't think we're close to recession, but it's a pretty uncomfortable place, fragile place to be.
Bearish 2026-08-12
Jan Hatzius (Goldman Sachs) tells Fox Business that the roughly 70,000 one-month drop in Goldman's estimate of underlying US job creation is a pretty sharp slowdown.
A drop by almost 70,000 from one month to the next is quite a lot. It's a pretty sharp slowdown
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-12
Jan Hatzius (Goldman Sachs) tells Fox Business the US economy is doing pretty well, with GDP growing 2% to maybe 2.5%, his expectation for the next year or two.
I think it's doing pretty well. The GDP is growing at a 2% to maybe 2.5
Bullish 2026-08-12
Larry Kudlow (Fox Business) says the election-year US economy is booming in manufacturing, construction and durable goods.
Well, look, the election year economy is booming. I mean, there's no two ways about that, manufacturing and construction and durable goods and all the rest of it.
Bearish 2026-08-12
Larry Kudlow (Fox Business) tells Kevin Hassett the US is still running ~$2 trillion annual deficits despite the boom and he cannot understand why.
We're still doing these $2 trillion yearly deficits, and I'm trying to figure out why.
Neutral 2026-08-12
Kevin Hassett (National Economic Council) tells Larry Kudlow the administration has cut about 300,000 federal jobs, savings the CBO does not credit.
We've already cut about 300,000 federal government worker jobs, which the CBO has not given us credit for
Bullish 2026-08-12
Kevin Hassett (National Economic Council) tells Larry Kudlow the manufacturing boom (85,000 construction workers building factories) will produce growth and a dynamic revenue surplus.
we've got 85,000 construction workers building new factories, then you're going to get all sorts of growth, and that will give you a revenue surplus
Neutral 2026-08-12
Dibo tells Lacqua the US labor market is far from booming (about 20k jobs/month, 2.3% annualized wages), so wages are not an inflation source.
In fact if you look at the last three months the U.S. economy generated only 20,000 jobs on average per month and wages grew at an annualized pace of only 2.3 percent.
Neutral leaning · 2026-08-12
Dibo tells Lacqua the US labor market is in a no-hire, no-fire equilibrium with falling participation.
the U.S. labor market seems to be in an equilibrium where you're seeing there's no hire no fire labor market.
Bearish leaning · 2026-08-12
Ven Ram (Bloomberg MLIV) tells Lacqua a soft CPI could spark a tactical rally in Treasuries from record-short positioning, but yields resume rising because neither the Fed nor Treasury is addressing inflation or deficits.
I think there is a case for a tactical rally in duration but I do think that once those short positions are flushed out I think that then we'll set bill towards new short positions because the market is going to be episodic in its sell-offs
US 10-yr yield since this was said: 4.68% → 4.94% (+26 bp) · as of 2026-09-10
Bearish 2026-08-12
Larry Kudlow tells Fox Business the Senate will not pass the capital-gains indexing / home-sale exemption change even though it should.
Look I don't think again the bungling Senate will not pass this. They should. It should be part of the budget bill
Bearish hedged · 2026-08-12
Kudlow tells Fox Business a September budget bill carrying the capital-gains change is possible but he would not hold his breath.
you could get a budget done when they come back in September. All right I wouldn't hold my breath but you could theoretically get a decent budget done and stick this into it
Neutral 2026-08-12
Aditya Bhave (BofA Securities) tells CNBC the jobs number was not a disaster: with breakeven job growth near zero, a ~50k/month full-year average is fine and unemployment is falling.
still growing around 50,000 jobs per month, which I think is absolutely fine. And the unemployment rate's falling.
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-12
Thomas Hayes (Great Hill Capital) tells David Lin not to bet against the US consumer: unemployment is ~4%, confidence is turning up off multi-decade lows, and spending holds as long as oil stays roughly $70-90.
you never want to bet against the U.S. consumer when they have a job and with 4% unemployment rate, even though job growth is slowing, they do have jobs and their consumer confidence is turning up.
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-12
Thomas Hayes (Great Hill Capital) tells David Lin that back-to-school retail sales will come in stronger than expectations because the bar for the consumer is so low.
I think back to school is going to be relatively stronger than expectations.
Bearish 2026-08-11
Anita Krishna Gupta of Wealthbrix tells Bloomberg the ~5.3% 30-year yield will feed through mortgage and borrowing rates and definitely hurt the US consumer.
the impact on that on mortgage rates and borrowing rates. It's definitely going to impact the U.S. consumer.
Neutral 2026-08-11
Sunil Kumar of Spinneys tells Bloomberg that sea freight from Europe/UK to the Gulf jumped from ~$3,000 to ~$17,000 a container in April because of the war.
a sea fright was three thousand US dollars from Europe or in UK. On the month of April it moved into almost 17000 US dollars.
Bullish 2026-08-11
David Sacks tells Fox Business that AI capex plus Trump tax and energy policy is producing an economic boom.
So all of this is leading to an economic boom in the economy.
Bearish 2026-08-11
Ven Ram (Bloomberg) tells anchor Bonnie Quinn the Treasury selloff is deeply concerning: bond vigilantes are punishing fiscal profligacy and the inflation overshoot, keeping yields under upward pressure.
It is deeply concerning for the bond markets, and bond market vigilantes are in action clearly, and they want answers.
Neutral hedged · 2026-08-11
Laura Cooper tells Bonnie Quinn growth is still resilient, but a real-yield-driven test of 5% on the 10-year would be quite concerning.
But I think if we start to really test that 5 percent handle and the 10 year yield and that's real yield driven, perhaps then that could be quite concerning.
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-11
Joe Lavorgna says the economy is booming, with Q3 GDP growth possibly upwards of 6%, so last year's insurance cuts are no longer needed.
It looks like growth might be upwards of 6%. In the third quarter, margins are high. The general employment trends are good
Bullish 2026-08-11
Ed Yardeni tells Maggie Lake the US economy will remain resilient through the end of the decade.
the economy is going to remain resilient through the end of the decade
Bullish 2026-08-11
Yardeni tells Lake the economy is bulletproof because wealthy boomer consumers are bulletproof, plus the AI capex boom.
It's because the consumer is bulletproof. And on top of all that, we've got the AI capital spending boom.
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-11
Yardeni tells Lake the economy is doing very well on consumer, capex and deficit spending, though some growth is borrowed from the future.
and you've got an economy that's doing very well. But some of it could be borrowing from the future for sure. And some of it is ongoing resilience of the economy today.
Bearish leaning · 2026-08-10
Jeremy Siegel thinks the Atlanta Fed's over-5% Q3 GDP tracking is too optimistic and that 3-3.5% would still be enough to lift productivity and real wages.
atlanta fed thinks it's going to be over five percent i think that's too optimistic for the third quarter
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-10
Jeremy Siegel expects Q3 productivity growth to rebound after three quarters below the 15-year average.
i think we've had three quarters of us fallen back i'm looking for this next quarter to bring us back up
Neutral 2026-08-10
Mark Zandi of Moody's tells CNBC underlying US GDP growth is 2%, the same as last year and the first half of this year.
GDP growth is 2%. That's what it was last year. That's what his first half of this year.
Bearish 2026-08-10
Jim Caron tells Bloomberg 60/40 is not his favored allocation because the passive fixed-income 40 has returned about zero for five years and no longer hedges equities; he favors active, tactical bonds.
60/40 is not my favorite allocation for many reasons. The dominant reason is the 40. It's not the 60.
US 10-yr yield since this was said: 4.70% → 4.94% (+25 bp) · as of 2026-09-10
Neutral 2026-08-10
Thierry Wizman (Macquarie) tells the Bloomberg anchor unemployment fell to 4.1%, below the Fed's own 4.3% projection, so the labor market is tighter than the Fed expected.
We went from four point two percent to four point one percent. It's important to keep in mind that that four point one percent is below where the Federal Reserve itself in its summary of economic projections believed that the unemployment would be at this time of the year.
Bullish leaning · 2026-08-08
ARK ITK; productivity growth approaching 3%.
productivity growth is starting to approach that 3 percent level, and so that means that
Bullish 2026-08-06
Prof G Markets w/ Ed Elson; his case for why the market keeps hitting records: July bank credit data benign.
But right now, number one, the U.S. economy is very strong. All the banks reported mid-month in July, and the credit statistics were as benign as they possibly could be.
Steve Eisman · Investor; The Real Eisman Playbook host · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2crQa6Y3nMw @3:00 ↗
Bullish 2026-08-06
Las Vegas campaign speech soundbite; Nevada job creation and food-stamp decline.
here in nevada we've created over 40 000 new jobs and lifted nearly 100 000 Nevadans off of food stamps and they don't want
Bullish 2026-08-03
Dismisses weak Q2 GDP as SPR technical adjustment; core strong.
We released a big amount of oil from Strategic Patrol and Reserve and that came out of GDP so the good news is core GDP was actually quite strong Ed and you know we're seeing manufacturing is doing well the jobs numbers are strong the consumer is strong so it was a technical adjustment in the number I wouldn't worry about it.
Scott Bessent · U.S. Treasury Secretary · Fox Business ↗
Bullish 2026-07-31
falsifiable: the inventory drawdown reverses next quarter
“that's going to be rebuilt, and so that's going to be a tailwind coming into next quarter”
Bullish 2026-07-31
no-recession call citing the resilient consumer
“These folks that are worried about a recession, we don't see anything in the data that we're looking at that gives us any concern”
Eddie Ghabour · Key Advisors Wealth Management · Fox Business ↗
Bullish 2026-07-31
contrarian vs the everything-is-rigged mood
“everyone is getting richer. The top 1% has gotten way, way richer.”
Allison Schrager · Bloomberg Opinion / Manhattan Institute · Bloomberg ↗
Bearish 2026-07-31
his K-shaped frame: 60 percent own homes and stocks, 40 percent rent and mostly don't
“the K the branches of the K have been diverging more widely in the last six or seven years”
Bullish 2026-07-30
asked if the soft GDP print worries him; garble of cause for concern
“No, no cost for concern whatsoever.”
Kevin Headland · Manulife Investment Management · BNN Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-22
The town eliminated all public debt without raising taxes while expanding services and cutting business fees 25 percent @1:20. 'Mandami' is a whisper garble of NYC Mayor Mamdani, invoked by the host @1:49. Adds 'The more the government keeps its nose out of the business of the individual, the better they will be' @2:30. Host's own 'socialist mayors' framing not filed (host-speaking, but it is the mayor taking the position here).
“But to Mayor Mandami and every socialist in America, understand this. Keep your hands out of the pockets of working American men and women and they will thrive.”
John David Longo · Mayor of Slippery Rock, Pennsylvania · Fox Business ↗
Bearish 2026-07-21
His 'uncertainty scorecard' @1:18: the open-ended US-Iran war ('That's the thing about war. You don't know exactly when it's going to end' @1:12), new Canada tariffs that 'probably violate our current trade agreements' @1:31 so 'you can't depend on the trade agreements', and no real plan on tech regulation. Aired with oil around $85 and gas at a $4.02 national average.
“So three massive uncertainty factors, which I think are no doubt a drag on the economy right now and probably going forward.”
James Pethokoukis · American Enterprise Institute · CNBC ↗
Bullish 2026-07-21
Clip runs with GM's better-than-expected results; average transaction price $52,000, 'Pricing has been relatively flat' @2:23, 42% truck share with volumes 'up a little bit. We expect them to be flat for the year' @2:42 due to a model changeover that should give 'even more momentum into 2027' @2:55.
“So I would say the consumer's been resilient in every measure that we're looking at across the portfolio.”
Paul Jacobson · General Motors · CNBC ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-07-21
He says 'the Democrats clearly have a strategy to shut down the government again' @4:08 when funding runs out September 30, strongly supports the House CR to December 4 @4:29, and argues the December 4 timeline four weeks past the election 'provides a lot of room for more reasonable negotiation' @6:19. He also expects Russia sanctions and reconciliation 3.0 can get done before the recess.
“I think we can get enough Democrats to support a continuing resolution who are serious about appropriating and that would be much to Chuck Schumer chagrin.”
Kevin Cramer · U.S. Senate · Fox Business ↗
Bullish 2026-07-21
Replayed clip from the previous day's Mornings with Maria interview: software-defined ships 'built cheaper and at higher rates' @6:24 and new shipyards 'more efficient than the shipyards that the Chinese have' @6:15; 'We don't need to go and build 1200 foot cargo containers. We certainly can and we will be able to at Port Alpha' @6:28. Filed from this tape because the original Jul 20 interview tape is not in this assignment; note the duplicate airing.
“We are going to beat China in the new way. We are going to outproduce China by building autonomous vessels, by building the future of the maritime industry”
Dino Mavrookas · Saronic Technologies · Fox Business ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-20
With $4 gas back and refunds spent, Gunther says even higher earners are getting discerning, citing months of dollar-store growth driven mostly by high-income consumers looking to save.
“we are seeing some signs of higher income consumers not necessarily pulling back, but being more discerning about how they spend.”
Michael Gunther · Consumer Edge · CNBC ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-07-20
Referring to the One Big Beautiful Bill's fiscal boost (a nearby segment garbles as 'it's having a really bad time'). He pairs it with ISM manufacturing as 'a really good leading indicator of small caps doing better' (@48:33) and points to equal-weight S&P outperforming cap-weight; recommends financials, health care, industrials.
“We are estimating it's having about a 1.1 percent impact on gdp growth”
Andy Goldberg · Nomura Asset Management · Bloomberg ↗
Bullish 2026-07-20
The commitments around it: 'We're going to invest billions of dollars. We're going to create 10,000 jobs. We're going to bring online 150,000 gross tons of shipbuilding capacity pretty much on our first phase' @4:24, which he sizes at '1.5x the total shipbuilding capacity in this country today' @4:37.
“We're going to break ground in '26. We're going to be operational in '28. That's because that's what this country needs. We need to be able to build ships again.”
Dino Mavrookas · Saronic Technologies · Fox Business ↗
Bullish 2026-07-20
Directly answering 'do you think the U.S. can beat China when it comes to shipbuilding and autonomous vessels?' He concedes the conventional gap - 'China outbuilds us 230 to 1' @3:52 and 'We have 0.1 percent of shipbuilding capacity' @3:59 - and stakes the win on asymmetric autonomy, 'ships that can be built cheaper and at higher rates and controlled by software' @9:13.
“We are going to beat China in the new way. We are going to outproduce China by building autonomous vessels, by building the future of the maritime industry, by building software-defined platforms”
Dino Mavrookas · Saronic Technologies · Fox Business ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-07-20
Referring to the president's request: 'He's requested $1.5 trillion for the new budget moving forward' @8:15; today's baseline is 'the Department of War is only spending 1% on autonomy' @8:05, and he wants the 99/1 mix shifted 'more towards new systems' @8:32. Also: 'This is the fastest I have seen the government move on anything in my lifetime. That said, we're still in the early days, like very, very early innings' @7:51.
“A lot of that is going to go towards autonomy, and that's exactly what we need.”
Dino Mavrookas · Saronic Technologies · Fox Business ↗
Bearish 2026-07-20
Asked whether Alameda County's newly approved reparations plan will produce cash payments; his basis: 'most of these cities and counties and state governments... just don't have the cash' @0:34 and Alameda 'came into the year with a 91 million budget deficit' @1:03. His closing swipe that the Newsom diaper-contract 'stench is going to follow him on the campaign trail as he heads out for 2028' @3:23 is rhetorical, not filed separately.
“They talk about reparations, they set up committees to study reparations, and then when it comes to paying cash reparations, they never deliver.”
Joel Pollak · California Post · Fox Business ↗
Bullish 2026-07-20
Answering why real household income rose more under Trump than Biden, he opens 'Solely because of policies, Larry, that's all it is' @1:01 and claims the tax bill 'paid for itself in revenues' @1:17. Retrospective attribution on charts the host displays.
“He did the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act in the first term, he made it permanent in the second term, and both of those led to an increase in the growth rate of the U.S.”
Art Laffer · Laffer Associates · Fox Business ↗
Bullish 2026-07-20
He cites an $8,000 real median income increase over Trump's five and a half years as president @2:12, credits 'the tax cuts... drill baby drill... and deregulation of the economy' @2:41. He addresses the host as Larry.
“So if you take into account the money that people saved on their taxes, you're talking about take-home pay for middle-class families, $10,000 higher.”
Steve Moore · Committee to Unleash Prosperity / WABC host · Fox Business ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-07-17
Balanced against a notable secondhand data point he reports: CEOs now 'think the economy is a one and a half percent economy. They would have thought it was a two to two and a half percent economy earlier in the year' (@2:20), with 'a level of caution that I haven't seen so much before' (@2:15), consumers through their savings, Michigan confidence at all-time lows, and energy-price turbulence.
“And I do believe the economy remains incredibly resilient for all the reasons everybody's thought over the past couple of years”
Blair Efron · Centerview Partners · Bloomberg ↗
Bearish hedged · 2026-07-17
Show billed as her explaining 'why she believes recession risks are building.' Her tells: metals no longer wowing, dollar breaking under 100, TLT reclaiming its 50-day, plus midterm-cycle pressure and war confidence shocks: 'There's a lot of cracks that if they got bigger, we would see that in those areas that I just mentioned.' @12:41. She disarms it herself: 'I don't want people to run out and go, oh, Mish said there's a recession'; host recap: 'Not saying that we're definitely gonna get a recession the next six, eight, 10 months, but she's seeing some cracks.' Notes XRT over 90 makes recession 'hard to make a case for... at this moment.'
“listen, I'm talking six to eight months out. It's a bold statement. If you look at the statistics, they're saying 10% chance of recession.”
Neutral 2026-07-17
Frames the K-shaped read: 'in the K-shaped paradigm, the high end is pretty strong selectively' @0:27, driven by 'the wealth effect and stock market performance globally' @0:33, while 'middle and low income has been under pressure' @0:38 from food, energy and healthcare inflation and is 'cutting back on discretionary spending' @0:55.
“the consumer is sentimentally weak but fundamentally strong. So consumer sentiment is something to watch.”
Bullish 2026-07-16
'corporate demand so far, this quarter's up 30% business demand' @3:08; 'I looked at the bookings from yesterday, as early as this morning, and just really no change, strength really across the board' @3:30.
“I think the economy is doing well. We have a strong economy, probably better than people appreciate, 'cause we're a pretty good real-time indicator of demand.”
Scott Kirby · United Airlines · CNBC ↗
Bullish 2026-07-16
'we're gonna have double digits in the mid to high teens for CapEx and GDP, the retail sales are strong, the labor market shows no signs of weakening now. It's actually appears to be firming. Claims are super low' @1:15-1:30; last year's 75bp of easing was based on labor-market concerns that 'now are misplaced' @1:36-1:44.
“I mean, the economy is booming, but there is certainly inflation pressure.”
Joe Lavorgna · SMBC Nikko Securities · CNBC ↗
Bullish 2026-07-16
'The labor market we think will continue to improve here' in the second half @2:32 - he flags this as where Carson differs from consensus. Notes the economy created only 120,000 jobs all of last year while recent months average 'well over 100', unemployment still low; 'AI is nearly half of all real GDP' over the last five quarters @2:40 and he wants the consumer to take the baton. 'We're following the hard data' @3:32; bank CEOs say 'consumers are strong across the board' @3:42.
“We don't see a recession. We see a strengthened labor market.”
Ryan Detrick · Carson Group · CNBC ↗
Bullish 2026-07-15
He concludes 'the consumer feels good and the economy is in a very good spot and could be in a great spot' @9:13, crediting top-down national mood over survey headlines and dismissing data-driven pessimism as headline snowballing @8:42.
“People feel good in this country. People are spending money. People are gonna continue to spend money.”
Bearish 2026-07-14
23 days of legislative business left to Sep 30; sees no Senate incentive to help; reopening 'could be lame duck' (@39:57)
“my prediction would be that they will, the government will shut down the end of September”
Sarah Chamberlain · Republican Main Street Partnership · Bloomberg Balance of Power ↗
Bearish hedged · 2026-07-14
Democratic strategist (Bully Pulpit International, fmr NSC spokesman); prefers 'a clean CR that gets us through election day' but sees Republican disarray and no Democratic incentive to hand pre-election wins
“I share unfortunately a little bit of Sarah's pessimism that we may be in another shutdown and I don't know when that ends.”
Adam Hodge · Bully Pulpit International · Bloomberg Balance of Power ↗
Bearish 2026-07-14
372 corporate bankruptcies in H1 2026, most in 15 years (S&P); LendingTree personal bankruptcies +50% y/y; 720K left the labor force, participation 61.5%, lowest since 1976 ex-COVID; 'companies cut costs the way they can with what they can control. And they can control headcount.' (@12:29)
“the greater the margin squeeze, the more companies are compelled”
Bearish 2026-07-14
On the 5% Billionaire Tax Act ballot measure (Nov); says roughly a trillion dollars of wealth has already left ('it's in the neighborhood'); founders with paper valuations get unpayable bills; he personally stays and pays
“some sort of quasi bankrupt moment”
Chamath · Social Capital · CNBC Squawk Pod ↗
Bearish 2026-07-13
MEANING GUARD: 2030-2032 depletion window is his citation of the trustees report, not his forecast; his own claim is 'never fully solved, only patchworks'
“I think it'll never be fully solved. We've had patchworks that come every decade or so when we see that the Social Security Trust Fund is going to run out of resources. And the most recent report says it's coming pretty soon, 2030, 2032.”
Randall Kroszner · Chicago Booth; fmr Fed governor · Bloomberg TV ↗
Bearish 2026-07-13
Adds: gold 'isn't going to be 4,000 forever. There is no math case' (@3:58, his framing of the level)
“but I can't even construct how $40 trillion of debt and a permanently long, higher for longer interest rate regime can possibly ever work.”
Neutral hedged · 2026-07-10
Reacting to BofA card-spending strength
“I just hope that people aren't just starting to stockpile debt again. I don't think that's the case. I do buy off on your thesis that the one big beautiful bill changes in the deductions, have netted people a few more dollars in their paycheck. And usually if people net two, they spend four. And that's my concern.”
Marcus Lemonis · Camping World; Fox Business contributor · Fox Business ↗
Bearish leaning · 2026-07-06
“is on the brink of defaults that are going to be so significant that if the federal government was called in to bail them out”
David Friedberg · Ohalo; All-In Podcast · YouTube ↗
Bearish leaning · 2026-07-06
“once it's on the ballot, I don't see why it wouldn't pass.”
David Sacks · Craft Ventures / All-In Podcast · YouTube ↗
Bullish 2026-07-06
Benchmarking his 8090 'software factory' on open-source vs frontier models:
“We just took down our recession probability odds over the next 12 months back to kind of the you know long term norm over the past week.”
Kamakshya Trivedi · Goldman Sachs · YouTube ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-07-06
Comparing data-center spending to the 1870s railroad boom:
“we've kind of coined the phrase ho-hum economy for the U.S. here in 2026.”
Garrett Melson · Natixis Investment Managers · YouTube ↗
Bullish 2026-07-03
Personal book: “I would always own a slug of the S&P… some real estate in my portfolio and some gold”; “I'm long Bitcoin and I'm committed to at least two or three four-year cycles… it's the best performing asset in the history of the world”
Bullish leaning · 2026-07-03
“There's no reason we should stop at four percent. We should be at 12 percent and 13 percent GDP”
Donald Trump · President of the United States · CNBC ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-07-03
Lee says the IPO wave boosts the economy via wealth effect and stocks do well until lockup supply hits.
My take is that the broad economy is going to benefit from all these IPOs because it's massive wealth unlock. The stock market will do well until the unlocks happen because at that point when the unlocks happen, you have to absorb all that supply
Bullish leaning · 2026-07-01
“I think I couldn't be more bullish on the economy”
Bob Nardelli · Former Chrysler / Home Depot CEO · Fox Business Mornings with Maria ↗
Bearish 2026-06-30
Savings-rate ladder on-air: 1970s 12.2% → 90s 7.2% → 2000s 4.2% → “now after a steady decline we are at two point six percent… pretty rock bottom”; auto-loan delinquencies “back to actually slightly above where it was at the time of the financial crisis”
Steve Rattner · Willett Advisors / Morning Joe · Morning Joe ↗
Bearish 2026-06-25
“the Gulf States have lost their liquidity”
Yanis Varoufakis · DiEM25 / fmr. Greek FinMin · YouTube interview ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-06-25
Rick Rule tells Kitco's Jeremy Safran that in the very near term US policymakers will let the market set rates, so US interest rates go higher.
And that suggests to me that interest rates will go higher in the US.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEbtmAWiaC0 @1:31 ↗
Bearish 2026-06-25
Rick Rule argues a 10-yr Treasury paying ~4.5% loses ~1.5% a year after ~3% inflation, so Treasuries are a losing real-terms hold.
Which means that if you buy the US 10 year treasury, getting paid, let's say 4.5, you aren't making 4.5. You're actually losing 1.5.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEbtmAWiaC0 @7:11 ↗
Neutral 2026-06-25
Rick Rule puts total US obligations (federal debt plus NPV of unfunded entitlements) at about $155 trillion, growing ~$4T a year.
If you combine those two numbers, the aggregate debt in the United States hovers around $155 trillion.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEbtmAWiaC0 @12:09 ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-06-25
Rick Rule says the $4.2B Wheaton-BHP stream is the start of a wave of by-product streaming transactions funding copper mines.
the recent transaction, the 4.2 billion dollar transaction between Wheaton and BHP, I think is the beginning of a trend.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEbtmAWiaC0 @21:01 ↗
Bullish 2026-06-25
Rick Rule expects at least $50B (2025 dollars; 70-80B nominal) of new precious-metals streaming transactions over the next 10 years.
I think minimally, there'll be $50 billion in new transactions in the next 10 years, minimally.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEbtmAWiaC0 @21:50 ↗
Bullish 2026-06-25
Rick Rule says more mining M&A is definitely coming (strategic consolidation, lateral mergers, discovery premiums), visible within about six months if junior share prices do not recover first.
We're definitely gonna see more deals. And you're gonna see all kinds of different deals.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEbtmAWiaC0 @39:57 ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-06-25
Rick Rule expects surprisingly high prices to be paid for major exploration discoveries over the next five years because majors' pipelines are depleted.
I think over the next five years, the prices that are gonna be paid for those discoveries are gonna be surprisingly stiff.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEbtmAWiaC0 @41:44 ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-06-25
Rick Rule says the 30-40% sell-off in quality juniors in 2026 makes accretive takeovers at ~50% premiums possible, which is very good for M&A.
the high quality juniors in 2026 have sold off by 30 or 40%, which is to say that an accretive deal can be made at say a 50% premium to current prices.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEbtmAWiaC0 @42:36 ↗
Bullish 2026-06-25
Rick Rule finds political change across Latin America (ex-Brazil) encouraging for mining investment, while noting he does not know how long it lasts.
I think the political change throughout Latin America, with the exception of Brazil, is extremely encouraging.
Rick Rule · Rule Investment Media / Rule Symposium · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hEbtmAWiaC0 @46:46 ↗
Bearish 2026-06-09
Todd 'Bubba' Horwitz tells Kitco true US unemployment measured by U6 is 8.5% and getting worse, versus the official U3 figure.
But true unemployment in this country under six months is 8.5% as of today, and getting worse
Bearish 2026-06-09
Todd 'Bubba' Horwitz tells Kitco 13% of credit cards are 90+ days past due, 6% of car loans and 4% of mortgages are in default, so the average American cannot afford to invest.
I mean, 13% of credit cards are 90 days past due or more. 6% of car loans are in default and 4% of mortgage are in default.
Bearish 2026-06-09
Todd 'Bubba' Horwitz tells Kitco the US is already in a recession, at least the bottom of the K-shaped economy, and it will get worse.
Yes, we're gonna have a recession. I think we're in a recession now.
Neutral 2026-05-22
Chamath Palihapitiya tells All-In that Dario Amodei's AI-fear messaging is a rational strategy to build a regulatory moat for Anthropic.
It makes enormous sense for Dario to try to create the boundary conditions for a regulatory moat because he will be inside of the tent pissing out.
Bullish leaning · 2026-05-22
Gavin Baker tells All-In that city bans on Waymo/Cybercab robotaxis will not persist, given 50,000 US road deaths a year and consumer convenience.
And then just from a convenience and quality of life perspective, I just don't think it's gonna persist.
Neutral leaning · 2026-05-22
David Friedberg tells All-In that the Trump-Xi summit produced aircraft and ag purchases but no grand de-escalation deal, and US-China rivalry will keep escalating.
but fundamentally the grand deal, the big deal that I would say reduces a deescalates tension probably didn't manifest as some had hoped it would.
Neutral hedged · 2026-05-22
Chamath Palihapitiya tells All-In the Trump-Xi trip was useful and productive, guessing real alignment on geopolitical next steps happened behind closed doors.
I think that it was a useful and productive trip.
Neutral 2026-05-22
Gavin Baker tells All-In that selling deprecated Nvidia GPUs to China is stabilizing and the best path to keep America ahead in AI, because it lowers the odds China builds its own ecosystem.
I think selling deprecated Nvidia GPUs to China lowers the odds of them developing their own alternative ecosystem
Nvidia since this was said: ▲ +1.4% · 215.3 → 218.4 · as of 2026-09-10
Bullish 2026-05-15
Marc Benioff tells All-In he expects the CEOs travelling with Trump to the Xi summit to come back with large order books (planes, chips, soybeans).
So I expect a lot of order books to come back.
Bullish leaning · 2026-05-15
Chamath Palihapitiya tells All-In that Andreessen Horowitz is marching from $100B toward $1T of AUM and will be the next Blackstone (no deadline).
They're marching towards a trillion. They're going to be the next blackstone
Neutral 2026-05-15
Chamath Palihapitiya tells All-In that within 18 months US chip fabs will be close enough to TSMC that Taiwan stops being a central strategic issue.
We're 18 months from Taiwan not being an important moment of conversation the way it is today.
Neutral 2026-05-15
Marc Benioff tells All-In that the Taiwan conflict is a nonsense issue and China and Taiwan will reconcile.
I don't agree with Neil Ferguson on that point. I think that this is a nonsense issue. I think China and Taiwan will reconcile.
Neutral leaning · 2026-05-15
David Friedberg tells All-In that an Indian monsoon failure is now highly probable this El Nino year, threatening 150 million farmers and risking a South Asian calorie deficit and economic crisis.
And the scariest one of all is if the monsoons fail, which is now a very high probability event in India.
Bullish hedged · 2026-05-15
David Friedberg tells All-In that a record El Nino could spike energy, electricity and commodity prices worldwide over the next year via crop failures (hedged).
But if you think about the second and third effects of this over the next year, you could see energy prices spiking and electricity spiking and the grid failing in parts of the Southwest, commodity prices spiking all over the world.
Neutral 2026-01-19
Peter Schiff tells the interviewer the US is broke, with a $38.6T and rising national debt plus larger unfunded liabilities.
We're broke. The United States has a thirty eight point six trillion dollar national debt and rising fast.
Bullish 2026-01-09
Raoul Pal tells Mando that human-centred assets like sports teams keep rising in value because AI cannot replace the human element (cites chess growing despite computers winning).
if you look at things like sports teams, they just keep going up and to the right in value. The reason being is they're human centered things.
Raoul Pal · Real Vision / Global Macro Investor · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lkERbyR1BI @17:08 ↗
Bullish leaning · 2026-01-09
Raoul Pal, summarising the GMI 2026 outlook he co-publishes, tells Mando the macro view is business cycle up and commodities up.
Julian spent a lot of time looking at the macro outlook and the simple macro outlook is business cycle go up, commodities go up
Raoul Pal · Real Vision / Global Macro Investor · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lkERbyR1BI @39:26 ↗
Bullish 2026-01-09
Raoul Pal tells Mando that over the next ten years digital art becomes an ultra-valuable human artifact in an AI-driven world; it is his biggest bet.
And I think digital art will become ultra valuable artifacts.
Raoul Pal · Real Vision / Global Macro Investor · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lkERbyR1BI @50:33 ↗
Neutral hedged · 2026-01-04
Raoul Pal guesses the no-tax-on-tips relief will reach workers sooner rather than later so the money starts flowing into the US economy ahead of the midterms.
And my guess is that will happen sooner rather than later, so that money can start filtering into the economy.
Raoul Pal · Real Vision / Global Macro Investor · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nslN690Odh0 @19:17 ↗
Bullish 2026-01-04
Raoul Pal says all his forward-looking indicators (financial conditions, global rate cuts) point to a strong US business cycle / rising ISM in 2026.
I've been doing business cycle analysis for 35 years. And really, really for 25 years as the main source of what I do, everything we look at says it's going to be strong, whether that's financial conditions
Raoul Pal · Real Vision / Global Macro Investor · https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nslN690Odh0 @40:28 ↗
Bullish 2025-10-30
Opens the show with 'The GDP is tracking near 4%.' @1:58; closes citing ~$4T of hyperscaler capex ('about ten times the size of the Manhattan Project' adjusted), trillions in foreign investment pledges including South Korea's $350B 'just today', and 'a level of coordination going on between Washington and Silicon Valley... that gives me cause for incredible hope.' @73:42.
“You can see 4 percent GDP growth on the horizon. We'll have our challenges. We'll have our ups and downs. These tend to be stairs, you know, stairs up rather than aligned straight up and to the right.”
Brad Gerstner · Altimeter Capital · BG2 ↗
Bullish 2025-06-30
Peter Schiff says US interest rates are going a lot higher from here and when they do the national debt cannot be sustained.
But the reality is rates are going a lot higher from here. They should be a lot higher from here. And when they do get a lot higher, we can't sustain the debt.
Bearish 2025-06-30
Peter Schiff says the US has already passed the point of no return on its national debt, not merely an unsustainable path.
We have already arrived at the point of no return as far as I'm concerned.
Bearish 2025-06-30
Peter Schiff says the US does not have the hottest economy in the world and factories are not springing up, citing the weak dollar as money leaving.
to say that factories are springing up all over the place is a complete lie. That's not happening. And we don't have the hottest economy in the world by a long shot.
Neutral 2025-06-30
Peter Schiff predicts the Trump Treasury will keep issuing short-dated debt rather than terming out, because heavy long-bond issuance would push long rates up.
As bonds mature, they're going to keep the maturity short. They're not going to go for long-term bonds either.

On the scoreboard

Voices in this debate who also have scored calls on the ledger.

Tom Lee · 3 of 12 correctCathie Wood · 3 of 5 correctChamath · 4 of 15 correctRaoul Pal · 0 of 3 correct

Head to head

Pick any two voices in this debate; their freshest claims go side by side.

Follow The U.S. Economy

One short email when this debate moves: new calls, reversals, verdicts. Plain words, free.

Before you trust the call, check the record.
We write down what public figures predict, in their exact words, and check the result when the deadline arrives. Every line links to its source. How we score · Corrections · The scoreboard · The data
© 2026 Pundit Rumble · independent and unaffiliated · updated every market morning · not investment advice.
Home Tape Debates Scores This week Insights