P U N D I T  R U M B L E The Tape Debates Scores This week Insights
← All topics

Fed

5 bullish · 24 bearish · 9 hold · 58 neutral · exact words, dated and sourced
Kevin WarshEd YardeniStephen MiranTom Lee+46

The tape

Jul 27
Aug 03
bullishbearishclaims filed per week

What the people who move markets are saying about this, in their own words. These are views on the record, not scored bets: when a call here grows a number and a deadline, it moves to the scoreboard. Newest first.

Neutral 2026-08-07
Bloomberg; the hike case rests on tariff/energy inflation the Fed cannot influence.
I think the argument for hiking seems to obviously rest on the shoulders of inflation and we would argue that this is not the kind of inflation that the Fed could actually impact. And so in
Bearish 2026-08-07
Bloomberg; raising rates is not costless; his case for the hold camp.
this many times raising rates is not a costless endeavor. Right
Neutral 2026-08-07
Apollo chief economist on CNBC; jobs report moved market pricing of the next hike from September to October.
Because at the moment, the market before the employment report was saying the Fed would hike in September. And now, of course, the market is saying, well, we pushed that out a month and now the hike It's likely going to come in October.
Neutral hedged · 2026-08-06
Former Fed Vice Chair; not three hikes, but has come to see a possibility of two, this year or early next.
learn a possibility of two this time or this year or early next year, because I
Neutral 2026-08-06
Former KC Fed president; strong supporter of no forward guidance.
And I think it's, I'm a strong supporter for not giving forward guidance.
Bullish hedged · 2026-08-05
Closing recommendation to maintain exposure to energy and materials , explicitly 'not because I think they're absolutely going to have a great next 12 months' but for risk management.
The biggest risk right now is not necessarily economic growth. It's inflation. And if we're going to have runaway inflation, it's going to be because energy and materials basically prices went too far. And your best defense against that is to have the stocks that benefit from high prices.
Tim Murray · Capital Market Strategist, T. Rowe Price · BNN Bloomberg ↗
Bullish hedged · 2026-08-05
Responding to host's note that Brian Moynihan's team sees possibly three rate hikes by end of the year.
Well, that's not impossible in my view. I mean, if inflation continues to move sideways or even get worse from here, then I think we're gonna have to start gradually adjusting interest rates to bring things back down.
Neel Kashkari · Minneapolis Fed President · CNBC ↗
Bullish 2026-08-05
After discussing whether balance-sheet shrinkage could substitute for hikes; he says the fed funds rate is the primary tool.
I'm not calling for a dramatic increase in interest rates. I'm simply saying, I don't see evidence that monetary policy is marginally restrictive right now, and I think we have more work to do to get inflation back down. And I would rather get going now in small steps than wait till later than we have a really entrenched inflation problem and have to raise rates aggressively then.
Neel Kashkari · Minneapolis Fed President · CNBC ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-08-05
Asked if the product performs better if the market falls , 'it's not like a buffered ETF.'
I would say that it performs well in sideways markets Remember these income strategies. I mean these premium income strategies that benefit from the volatility in the market So if the market is just a smooth straight line up probably not as good as that jagged return
Marc Zeitoun · Columbia Threadneedle · TheStreet ↗
Bearish hedged · 2026-08-05
With 30Y above 5 percent for 27 sessions and $40T debt; expects QE targeting 10s and 30s. EVENT: will, hedged.
well, I think they're going to try to use financial repression and That means the Fed is going to come in that would mean if that's true If my guess is true, that would mean an expansion of quantitative easing and that means where the Fed directly purchases government bonds from the market to suppress interest rates
Mark Thornton · Mises Institute - org from title/public record, not stated on tape · David Lin Report ↗
Bullish 2026-08-04
Opening framing of the dual-mandate trade-off in an interview marking her first year as Philadelphia Fed president.
We've got an economy that's pretty strong, right? We had, you know, second quarter growth came in, you know, and the top line number wasn't so awesome, but when you look at investment, you look at the consumer, you know, it looks really strong. You've got a labor market that's stable, and you've got inflation that's too high.
Anna Paulson · Philadelphia Fed President · CNBC ↗
Bearish 2026-08-04
Her core policy position, stated immediately after describing a strong economy with too-high inflation - the headline 'mildly restrictive' line of the interview.
And so I think we need, you know, policy that's mildly restrictive, and I think policy has been mildly restrictive to get underlying inflation back down to 2% in an acceptable time period.
Anna Paulson · Philadelphia Fed President · CNBC ↗
Bearish 2026-08-04
Interviewer asks whether the nine-to-three meeting vote was a close call for her; she says it was not.
So for me, it was, it was not a close call. I think that, you know, we're, to me, we've, you know, the evidence so far suggests we're in a mildly restrictive stance.
Anna Paulson · Philadelphia Fed President · CNBC ↗
Bearish 2026-08-04
Uses her 'measuring the depth of water in a pool with rocks being thrown in' analogy - tariffs and energy shocks obscure the underlying inflation level.
When I look at underlying inflation, when you try to strip out the effects of, of those things, you know, I see it somewhere in the range of two, four, two, eight, maybe there was a little bit of, you know, mild progress over the last several months, but I want to see more progress on that.
Anna Paulson · Philadelphia Fed President · CNBC ↗
Bearish 2026-08-04
'It's not the hyperscalers you married' exchange - massive AI capex funded by debt has changed the character of these stocks.
When you spend that much capex and then you issue that much debt, they're far more rates sensitive and they're far more sensitive when you think about that negative free cash flow. So it's not the same beast. And because of that, there really is a volatility regime shift and how volatile these stocks will be going forward that was not the same as the past.
Amy Wu Silverman · RBC Capital Markets, head of derivatives strategy · CNBC ↗
Bearish hedged · 2026-08-04
Immediately follows her 2.4-2.8% underlying-inflation estimate; interviewer interjects 'And that means higher rates in that sense, right?'; quote joins non-contiguous passages within the same answer (verified part-by-part)
You know, I think if we don't see that progress, then we have to be open to recalibrating monetary policy. You know, we need to get to 2%. ... Could be higher rates, could be, you know, same rates for longer
Anna Paulson · Philadelphia Fed President · CNBC ↗
Bearish hedged · 2026-08-04
Fed treats Iran inflation as transitory, the famous last words from 2022; may be forced into one hike. EVENT: will, hedged.
I think the Fed might have to raise rates one time, they're going to desperately try not to raise rates.
Ron Temple · Lazard chief market strategist · Bloomberg Television ↗
Bearish hedged · 2026-08-04
Sub-100bp IG spreads vs ~150 historical as a government-health warning.
I mean, if you look at the spreads between, you know, the 10-year corporate investment grade instrument versus the 10-year, I think if historically it's 150 basis point spread, I think we're under 100 now, which could tell you one or two things. Either corporates are getting a lot more healthy or the government's getting a little less healthy. So I do think there is a race for capital.
Eric Cantor · Moelis vice chair, fmr House Majority Leader · Bloomberg Television ↗
Bearish 2026-08-03
The long-end selloff is Warsh's plan working; borrowing keeps getting pricier. EVENT: will.
So Kevin is saying, look, the market is doing my job. They're making the ability to borrow money out on the curve more and more expensive. It's going to continue to get more expensive.
Neutral leaning · 2026-08-03
Warsh uses August incl. Jackson Hole to bake a plan for September. EVENT: will, dated.
he's going to have the month of August before the September meeting to come out and deliver a relatively-baked plan in his mind. He's not going to give you the big plan, but he himself will have a highly-baked plan.
Bearish 2026-08-03
Base case: Iran deal, crude down, Fed done; next move a cut in 2027. EVENT: will, dated.
No. Again, going back to what we think Trump wants a deal. And therefore we don't expect that to play out and ultimately crude oil prices to come back down. And if that's the case, then I think Warsh has a little bit more leeway. And if we get through this window, which I would say is between, you know, the September meeting till the end of the year, then I think we're we're done. The next move is going to be a cut in twenty twenty seven.
Derek Halpenny · MUFG head of global markets research · Bloomberg Television ↗
Bearish leaning · 2026-08-03
On Warsh's non-committal presser; steep curve says rates should be higher. EVENT: conditional, dated September.
So therefore if they don't hike in September, of course, then the market will just ask even more questions about what is now the plan.
Neutral leaning · 2026-08-02
Base case: PCE ~3.3 by year-end and Fed on hold all year; failure mode (hikes) stated on tape. EVENT: will, dated.
Our view is that inflation comes down to around 3.3 or so by the end of the year and could diminish further in 2027. And if that's right, then we think the Fed can stay on hold for the rest of the year.
Mike Gapen · Morgan Stanley chief US economist · Prof G Markets ↗
Bearish 2026-08-02
Anti-consensus: no hike; next Fed move is a series of 50bp cuts triggered by an equity reversion. EVENT: will.
think the next move from the Fed will be a series of 50 basis point cuts, and a normal reversion cycle in the stock market, which means recession, but that
Mike McGlone · Bloomberg Intelligence senior commodity strategist · Kitco News ↗
Bullish 2026-08-02
Long bonds the best H2 trade; 30Y toward 4 percent if equities fall.
So I look at treasury bonds right now as basically a put on the stock market with positive carry and no time decay.
Mike McGlone · Bloomberg Intelligence senior commodity strategist · Kitco News ↗
Neutral 2026-08-01
defense of the chair against the tantrum; Worsch = Warsh garble
“Kevin Worsch said and did exactly what he's been telegraphing for several months that he was going to do”
Lisa Shalett · Morgan Stanley Wealth Management · Fox Business ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-08-01
no hike unless data forces it; task forces broaden the data set in January
“I don't think he's going to go there unless the data pushes him. The market is trying to push him”
Lisa Shalett · Morgan Stanley Wealth Management · Fox Business ↗
Neutral 2026-07-31
warns a September tightening under Warsh would be a policy mistake
“I'm concerned that the Fed is going to make a mistake and tighten, do some type of tightening in September”
Eddie Ghabour · Key Advisors Wealth Management · Fox Business ↗
Neutral 2026-07-31
argues hike damage exceeds benefit; bond market already tightening
“a 25 or even 50 basis point rate hike is not going to get inflation down to 2%”
Eddie Ghabour · Key Advisors Wealth Management · Fox Business ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-31
rejects the Fed-credibility-problem framing as too early
“I don't. I think that's too hard an assessment, too early at least”
Lauren van Biljon · Allspring Global Investments · Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-31
citing the 0.1 monthly PCE drop to defend the hold
“the data right now are taking the pressure off the Fed. And I think that the markets will get around to seeing that”
Kevin Hassett · National Economic Council · Bloomberg ↗
Bearish 2026-07-31
Warsh's first presser gave no reaction function despite three dissents
“The silence of wars was really quite deafening and the financial markets basically said thumbs down”
Bill Dudley · former New York Fed president · Bloomberg ↗
Bearish 2026-07-31
reads Wednesday's curve reaction as markets marking down Fed credibility
“the 30-year yield went up, the 10-year yield went up and two-year yields dropped really was a sign that there was a loss of credibility”
Bill Dudley · former New York Fed president · Bloomberg ↗
Bearish 2026-07-31
the credibility damage as self-inflicted; Worsch = Warsh garble
“this is a really own goal on Kevin Worsch's part”
Bill Dudley · former New York Fed president · Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-31
the last 72 hours of market action force a September tightening to regain credibility
“increases the pressure on the Fed to act in September. If it's a jump ball in September, you almost need to tighten now”
Bill Dudley · former New York Fed president · Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-31
conditional on the host's hypothetical of the bulk of the FOMC voting against the chair; he prefaces that he doubts it gets there
“I don't think we would get to that. I think at that point, Warsh would throw in the towel and vote with the majority”
Bill Dudley · former New York Fed president · Bloomberg ↗
Bearish 2026-07-31
why Warsh cannot outsource policy to markets; the rate path becomes indeterminate
“Markets don't price to what the Fed should do. They price to what they think the Fed will do”
Bill Dudley · former New York Fed president · Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-31
the Fed boxed itself in with forward guidance; not communicating well right now
“there's two things I've changed my mind about in the last five years. One is drug legalization, and the other is monetary policy transparency.”
Allison Schrager · Bloomberg Opinion / Manhattan Institute · Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-31
endorsing Anna Wong's critique after Warsh left task forces open to recommending other inflation measures; whisper doubles it's is
“an inflation targeting central bank needs to be clear about what it is it's is targeting”
Neutral 2026-07-31
the hall-of-mirrors problem with Warsh taking his cue from the bond market
“the central bank looks at the market. The market looks at the central bank it gets circular”
Neutral hedged · 2026-07-31
the next real signal window for Warsh
“chairs have used Jackson Hole as sort of a sneak preview of coming attractions at the September November and December meetings”
Neutral 2026-07-31
what replaces guidance: a known reaction function
“If you're not going to do forward guidance then it's incumbent for the markets to have a broad understanding of how the central bank will react to data”
Neutral hedged · 2026-07-31
his read of the chair; two CPI reports land before September
“Worsch is maybe closer to the hawks than most believe”
Neutral 2026-07-31
argues the market misheard the presser; 2 percent commitment plus balance-sheet reduction
“Kevin Worsch, I think, was a lot more hawkish than everybody heard”
Neutral 2026-07-31
defends the hold against the dissenters
“If you look at the data, there was no reason to hike at this rate, at this time”
Mohamed El-Erian · Allianz / Queens' College · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-31
the selloff reflects lost hand-holding, not policy error; codependency has gone too far
“the market is nervous that its training wheels are being taken off”
Mohamed El-Erian · Allianz / Queens' College · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-31
the dissents show where the committee wants rates to go
“The dissents were the most important”
Neutral 2026-07-31
employment side in the best shape he can remember
“the Fed really just needs to worry about the one side of its mandate right now, which is inflation”
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-31
a quieter Fed must act more; sees no willingness yet
“maybe it's going to actually need to move rates more aggressively”
Neutral hedged · 2026-07-31
conditional warning: Fed credibility currently enormous and market inflation expectations tame; deficit on the credibility bank only if Warsh fails to put his money where his mouth is
“going into deficit on the credibility bank”
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-31
three one-sided dissents near a control tipping point
“once you get over three, I think you're beginning to really tilt on who's controlling the Fed”
Bearish leaning · 2026-07-31
This Week In Focus w/ Jerry Saffron; argues the bond market's reaction shows investors don't believe Warsh's inflation talk.
going to get this under control," the market right now is telling me they're not buying it
Neutral 2026-07-30
his framing of the three dissents
“I asked for a good family fight and I got one.”
Neutral 2026-07-30
the former vice chair on the presser vs the vote
“it didn't sound quite as hawkish in my ears”
Roger Ferguson · Former Federal Reserve vice chair · CNBC ↗
Bearish leaning · 2026-07-30
if resolve is not backed by action
“the words will start to sound a little hollow”
Roger Ferguson · Former Federal Reserve vice chair · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-30
the hawk-talker vs the hold-voter
“Will the real Walsh stand up here?”
Ven Ram · Bloomberg MLIV · Bloomberg Television ↗
Neutral 2026-07-30
the administration's defense of Warsh
“the dissents all came from regional Fed presidents not from the actual governors”
Kevin Hassett · National Economic Council · Bloomberg Television ↗
Bearish leaning · 2026-07-30
his reading of the hawkish talk
“it was all perform ative, that it was all pre-approved”
Brien Lundin · Gold Newsletter / New Orleans Investment Conference · David Lin Report ↗
Neutral 2026-07-30
Warsh's hawkish June pivot meant a July hike had to follow; the hold failed his credibility test
“if you pivot in June from easing to tightening as a stance, then I think by July you have to deliver”
Ed Yardeni · Yardeni Research · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-30
defends withholding forward guidance; presser replay on Real Yield
“Market participants are learning to play the ball not the referee and market prices will continue to respond in the direction and magnitude they see fit.”
Kevin Warsh · Federal Reserve · Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-30
celebrates the three-dissent meeting as his intended open-debate model
“It was a real family fight. That's the better way to get policy right. That's our North Star.”
Kevin Warsh · Federal Reserve · Bloomberg ↗
Bearish 2026-07-30
Warsh is abdicating the Fed's core job and will be forced back to guidance
“You've got to learn from the past. You have to interpret the present. You have to forecast the future. At the moment the chair is refusing to do all three.”
Ed Al-Hussainy · Columbia Threadneedle · Bloomberg ↗
Bearish leaning · 2026-07-30
Fed outsourcing policy to markets creates a hall-of-mirrors feedback loop
“There's the danger of kind of creating a Hall and Mirrors effect.”
Ed Al-Hussainy · Columbia Threadneedle · Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-30
endorses Warsh's zero forward guidance as deliberate outsourcing
“Don't expect the Fed to tell you the direction. Just look at the numbers and make your own assessment as simple as that.”
Nicolo Bocchin · Azimut Group · Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-30
inflation fades within six-to-nine months toward 2%, hikes now would become cuts
“We don't need to hike rates now to cut them in nine months time time.”
Nicolo Bocchin · Azimut Group · Bloomberg ↗
Neutral 2026-07-30
the three hike dissents are the same April dissenters, not new hawkish momentum
“I think people are reading too much into it this time.”
Neutral 2026-07-29
why a hike today would be unprecedented, BofA analysis since the early 90s. truncated referent: 'of a Fed moving in that direction'; his point is a hike would SHOCK, not that one comes
“we've never seen the market price less than a 60% probability”
Mark Cabana · Bank of America Securities · CNBC ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-29
the inflation miss he counts
“it's been 62 months, five years since the Fed last hit its inflation target”
Mark Cabana · Bank of America Securities · CNBC ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-29
his dissent math: two dissents if hold, zero if hike. scoped: from a dissent perspective only; he separately says a hike would be a big surprise
“the path of least resistance just from a descent perspective would indicate a hike at this meeting, not a hold”
Mark Cabana · Bank of America Securities · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-29
how the decision concentrates in Warsh. reporter framing, deliberate hyperbole
“only one matters today and that is the new chair, Kevin Warsh”
Neutral 2026-07-29
Volcker within months; Yellen the only recent exception at 22 months. context framing of surprise risk, not a forecast
“The history of new Fed chairs is that they tend to raise rates very quickly after taking office”
Hold leaning · 2026-07-29
BlackRock APAC fixed income read on today
“I don't see a need for the Fed to rush into either a hike or a cut”
Neutral 2026-07-29
the chair's statement after the 9-3 hold
“There is no soft inflation target. There is no soft implicit target, not on this committee's watch.”
Kevin Warsh · Federal Reserve · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-29
his credibility line
“This Fed will not waver.”
Kevin Warsh · Federal Reserve · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-29
his case for pulling forward guidance
“Market participants are learning to play the ball, not the referee”
Kevin Warsh · Federal Reserve · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-29
answering impatience about delivering 2%
“the suggestion that we're going to be able to do it with our magic wand is one I want to dis abuse you and everyone else of”
Kevin Warsh · Federal Reserve · CNBC ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-29
markets doing the tightening for the Fed
“have tightened financial conditions in this intra-meeting period”
Kevin Warsh · Federal Reserve · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-29
DoubleLine read of the presser; whisper garbles dovish as dumbish, sub_fix territory
“Warsh was a little bit more dumbish than people expected which is why you're seeing a rally on the two year”
Ken Shinoda · DoubleLine Capital · Bloomberg Television ↗
Neutral 2026-07-29
what the long end is demanding
“The market wants hikes. The market wants fighting of inflation.”
Ken Shinoda · DoubleLine Capital · Bloomberg Television ↗
Bearish 2026-07-29
the market is not pricing the September hike the vote implied
“the market's saying we don't believe that the Fed is necessarily going to be hiking in September”
Bearish 2026-07-29
her read of the chair's posture
“rather than doing watchful thinking, he's really doing wishful thinking”
Neutral 2026-07-28
what the Fed should do at this meeting
“Hike. Hike now, hike tomorrow.”
Joe Lavorgna · SMBC Nikko Securities · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-28
his case for tightening
“the Fed has missed its inflation target going on six years”
Joe Lavorgna · SMBC Nikko Securities · CNBC ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-28
her read as a former Fed governor; she still expects no change. trailing 'Hike.' may be a clarification of whisper 'high'; her baseline is a hold
“I think a good case can be made for a quarter point high. Hike.”
Betsy Duke · Former Federal Reserve governor · Bloomberg Television ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-28
dissent forecast for today
“I think you may very well see diss ents after this meeting”
Betsy Duke · Former Federal Reserve governor · Bloomberg Television ↗
Hold 2026-07-28
his prescription for today. STRENGTH corrected leaning->firm: unhedged prescription
“the Fed should stay on hold based on this”
Stephen Miran · Federal Reserve · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-28
the consensus he reports the day before. STANCE corrected: the survey's consensus, not McKee's call
“Eighty-seven of the 88 economists who participate in our Bloomberg survey say the Fed is going to leave rates on hold”
Hold leaning · 2026-07-27
Wednesday FOMC expectation. her next-move view is a hike; do not read as dovish
“our expectation is not that we're gonna get a hike this week”
Hold 2026-07-27
Wednesday FOMC expectation. paired with hawkish worry on tape
“I don't think there's going to be any rate increase at all on Wednesday”
Jeremy Siegel · Wharton · CNBC ↗
Hold 2026-07-27
Wednesday FOMC expectation. he concedes hike probability has risen
“I'm expecting them to do absolutely nothing”
Haig Bathgate · Callanish Capital · Bloomberg Television ↗
Neutral leaning · 2026-07-27
directional call on the Fed's next move, timing not this week. team view with an explicit timing hedge
“the most likely next move from the Fed is a hike”
Hold 2026-07-27
his Fed call for this week
“I wouldn't expect them to raise rates.”
Tom Lee · Fundstrat Global Advisors · CNBC ↗
Neutral 2026-07-27
what hike risk does to the macro community. STANCE corrected bear->neutral: color about analyst psychology
“it's like you're squeezing their head in a vice”
Lori Calvasina · RBC Capital Markets · CNBC ↗
Hold 2026-07-24
whether the Fed should hike this week. advice-type (should), normative not predictive; he separately warns the Fed may hike anyway
“I wouldn't be hiking here.”
Warren Pies · 3Fourteen Research · CNBC ↗
Hold 2026-07-24
oil-shock argument against hiking. a maxim deployed as his no-hike argument, not a prediction of what the Fed does
“you don't hike into a supply induced spike”
Warren Pies · 3Fourteen Research · CNBC ↗
Hold hedged · 2026-07-24
what the Fed should do next week. advice-type whose meaning is directional toward hold; he separately wants the balance sheet cut
“doing nothing would be probably the best thing to do”
Art Laffer · Laffer Associates · Fox Business ↗

On the scoreboard

Voices in this debate who also have scored calls on the ledger.

Tom Lee · 3 of 12 correct

Head to head

Pick any two voices in this debate; their freshest claims go side by side.

Follow Fed

One short email when this debate moves: new calls, reversals, verdicts. Plain words, free.

Before you trust the call, check the record.
We write down what public figures predict, in their exact words, and check the result when the deadline arrives. Every line links to its source. How we score · Corrections · The scoreboard · The data
© 2026 Pundit Rumble · independent and unaffiliated · updated every market morning · not investment advice.
Home Tape Debates Scores This week Insights